Results 1 to 4 of 4

Thread: What description, and Planchet error?

  1. Talking What description, and Planchet error?

    Hello folks, I have a few questions.

    First I found a 1958D penny that has truncated designes and lettering on the rim.
    These devices look to be about the right size as if a penny planchet was use to test the distance of the dies for a quarter, with the test-piece being re-struck as a penny. What would I call this? I still haven't matched the exact designs to any other coin yet. I also bought an indian-head penny that bears the same kind of evidence.

    Secondly, I have an 1877 indian-head penny, that has distinctly differing thickness to the rims from one side to the other. If a non uniform thickness to the planchet is struck, I'd imagine that the design would be weak where the planchet is thinnest. Is a non uniform planchet considered an error/variety? Would this non-uniform strike lessen the grade? (I've seen some dimes that were struck from rusty dies that graded in ms even though they looked G at best.)

    Thanks for your help, and if I can find any more of those "rim-struck" coins I'll try to pick them up.

    Russell Wilcoxon

  2. #2


    Member of: ANA, CCC, CONECA, Fly-in-club, FUN, NLG & T.E.V.E.C.

  3. #3


    Your 1958-D cent was probably lodged in an aluminum ring that bore some sort of advertising slogan. Occasionally, design elements meant for the ring slop over onto the rim of the cent. Such "encased cents" can be found through most of the 20th century. Your Indian cent probably owes its odd features to the same technology.

    The 1877 cent may show the effect of a tilted die (vertical misalignment). This concentrates force at one pole, forcing coin metal to squeeze into the gap between die neck and collar (a "finned dim"). This makes the edge on that side appear thicker. Since this is a rare and heavily counterfeited date, you may have a counterfeit.
    Mike Diamond. Error coin writer and researcher.

  4. Default Further descrption

    Thanks for your replies, and so fast.

    I can see that I need to press my photography skills to elucidate more exactly what I've found. The lettering on Waveylines coin is much like what I have, except the design marks don't appear to relate to any design on the penny itself. The designs are on each side obv/rev and are similar to each other. (The 1958D that is) Your photos did help me to re-examine for related markings between the coin itself and the markings on the rims.

    The 1901 indian may have a relation I'll have to look closer. this coin has markings on the obv. side all around the rim with flat spots over the denticle, while the denticles on the rev are universally flat. Any of the flat spots have a mottled texture. I've seen this mottled texture on the back of a military medal. (Are those made through the mint?)

    I'll try and get the photos up soon.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts