Welcome!

Log in or register to take part.

CONECA (pronounced: CŌ´NECA) is a national numismatic organization devoted to the education of error and variety coin collectors. CONECA focuses on many error and variety specialties, including doubled dies, Repunched mintmarks, multiple errors, clips, double strikes, off-metals and off-centers—just to name a few. In addition to its website, CONECA publishes an educational journal, The Errorscope, which is printed and mailed to members bimonthly. CONECA offers a lending library, examination, listing and attribution services; it holds annual meetings at major conventions (referred to as Errorama) around the country.

CONECA was formed through a merger of CONE and NECA in early 1983. To learn more about the fascinating HISTORY OF THE ERROR HOBBY and THE HISTORY OF CONECA, we encourage you to visit us our main site Here

If you're not a member and would like to join see our Membership Application

We thank everybody who has helped make CONECA the great success that it is today!

Register Now

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

2007-P George Washington Dollar - Elongated Third Ray on the Reverse -

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 2007-P George Washington Dollar - Elongated Third Ray on the Reverse -

    Have any of you guys ever seen one of these actually attributed?

  • #2
    Attributed as what? Do you have a photo?
    Bob Piazza
    Lincoln Cent Attributer

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by mustbebob View Post
      Attributed as what? Do you have a photo?
      Attributed as one of these:

      2007-P George Washington Dollar - "Elongated Third Ray on the Reverse"

      Yes, I have a photo but I want to know if one of these has ever been attributed first.

      Comment


      • #4
        Yes, I have a photo but I want to know if one of these has ever been attributed first.
        Sorry you insist on playing games here. Can't help you because I can't see what you are talking about. If you refuse to post the pic, you need to research this info yourself.
        Bob Piazza
        Lincoln Cent Attributer

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by mustbebob View Post

          Sorry you insist on playing games here. Can't help you because I can't see what you are talking about. If you refuse to post the pic, you need to research this info yourself.
          Would you mind explaining to me EXACTLY how I'm playing games here?? I'm not refusing to post pictures!! Pictures have nothing to do with the question of this thread! Did you actually read my first post and see the subject line??....probably not!

          The question is and was: Have any of you guys ever seen one of these actually attributed? For a 2007-P George Washington Dollar - Elongated Third Ray on the Reverse.

          Again, the question has nothing to do with pictures!

          Let me ask you a question: Are you even familiar with this coin?... Probably not. That's why you're accusing me of playing games, because you don't have an answer to my question. If you don't have an answer, just say you don't know. Don't attack me!! I don't appreciate you accusing me of playing games! You get my point??
          Last edited by HeartWith02; 10-27-2021, 07:48 PM.

          Comment


          • #6
            Let's get something straight. If you refuse to submit a photo, how am I supposed to know what you are talking about? You say it's an elongated ray. How long is it? How thick is it? Is it perfectly straight? Does it look like a crack? Is it incuse or raised? Does it have any other features that could help us match it? How can I answer the question if you can't even show me what I need to be asking or looking for?

            Do you see where I am going with this? It's like saying I have a doubled die. Have any ever been attributed before? I have a die chip...have any over been reported before? There is a die crack from the corner of the memorial. Have any been reported? In order to be as accurate as possible, it would be nice to know specifics. I ask it all the time. I believe you have also when you reply to peoples posts.

            To me, your lack of posting a photo is a game with no rationale explanation. In order to give you my opinion, I need for you to cooperate. Our protocol required posting a photo and you have not and so far will not do that. Tell me why you won't. Are you afraid of something like maybe someone getting credit for something you want credit for? If that is the case, then let me know.

            You asked me if I am even familiar with this coin. I would love to answer that question, but I don't know what it looks like. I am just trying to do my job here. I have many sources that you can't even begin to know about to help me with issues just like this. I would use them to help answer the question, but will not even ask them if I can not give them as much information as possible.
            Bob Piazza
            Lincoln Cent Attributer

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by mustbebob View Post
              Let's get something straight. If you refuse to submit a photo, how am I supposed to know what you are talking about? You say it's an elongated ray. How long is it? How thick is it? Is it perfectly straight? Does it look like a crack? Is it incuse or raised? Does it have any other features that could help us match it? How can I answer the question if you can't even show me what I need to be asking or looking for?

              Do you see where I am going with this? It's like saying I have a doubled die. Have any ever been attributed before? I have a die chip...have any over been reported before? There is a die crack from the corner of the memorial. Have any been reported? In order to be as accurate as possible, it would be nice to know specifics. I ask it all the time. I believe you have also when you reply to peoples posts.

              To me, your lack of posting a photo is a game with no rationale explanation. In order to give you my opinion, I need for you to cooperate. Our protocol required posting a photo and you have not and so far will not do that. Tell me why you won't. Are you afraid of something like maybe someone getting credit for something you want credit for? If that is the case, then let me know.

              You asked me if I am even familiar with this coin. I would love to answer that question, but I don't know what it looks like. I am just trying to do my job here. I have many sources that you can't even begin to know about to help me with issues just like this. I would use them to help answer the question, but will not even ask them if I can not give them as much information as possible.
              Jeezzzz man, you're killin' me!! You can't be this THICK!! ARE YOU ACTUALLY READING WHAT I'M POSTING AND THE QUESTION I'M ASKING??

              I know DDO's have been attributed and slabbed, that's not my question.

              You just answered my question: You have no idea what I'm talking about or what this "2007-P George Washington Dollar - Elongated Third Ray on the Reverse" even looks like. I don't believe you are even aware of this variety or anomaly. I'm not asking you to attribute a coin I have.

              Okay, here's a picture of the "subject line" for you and what I'm talking about. You're probably going to need some of your "many sources" to figure this out!

              Again, for the 5th time.......all I want to know is (to your knowledge, or anyone else here) have one of these ever been attributed before? Jeezzzzz, it's an easy question!!

              I think I need to get Dr. Wiles.
              Attached Files
              Last edited by HeartWith02; 10-28-2021, 12:37 PM.

              Comment


              • #8
                Never heard of it or seen it attributed.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by CoinHunter View Post
                  Never heard of it or seen it attributed.
                  Thanks CoinHunter! Is Mike Diamond on this forum?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Now that was not difficult. As 'Thick" as you think I am, and as much as you wanted to make this more than what it was, all I wanted was a photo. Thank you very much for posting that photo. Now that I know exactly what you are talking about, I can tell you that I do indeed know about this coin (sorry to disappoint you).
                    I have examined others with so called 'extra rays', but I have NOT examined this one in hand. No examiner that I know has added this to their files because of the uncertainty surrounding it. As you know, It is not like the standard 'extra ray' as seen on some other dates (8th ray, curved ray etc.).
                    Thanks once again for adding the photo. I appreciate it.
                    Bob Piazza
                    Lincoln Cent Attributer

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by mustbebob View Post
                      Now that was not difficult. As 'Thick" as you think I am, and as much as you wanted to make this more than what it was, all I wanted was a photo. Thank you very much for posting that photo. Now that I know exactly what you are talking about, I can tell you that I do indeed know about this coin (sorry to disappoint you).
                      I have examined others with so called 'extra rays', but I have NOT examined this one in hand. No examiner that I know has added this to their files because of the uncertainty surrounding it. As you know, It is not like the standard 'extra ray' as seen on some other dates (8th ray, curved ray etc.).
                      Thanks once again for adding the photo. I appreciate it.
                      Your welcome.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Let me ask you a question. How many "CONECA" attributers actually review, monitor or read this forum/website?

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          CONECA higher up are busy doing other things than being on a forum. Attributions arent even ready yet.

                          This isnt a listed “Variety”. YET. So no, none will be graded as that. I have heard its going in the new CPG which I have no clue why. This will end up being some other made up CPG variety like the Re Engraved Lincolns or the No FG. Probably be huge when it’s released and then end up being worth less than the plastic its in. You would be better off keeping it til the CPG is released for a #. Then youll have all them FS chasers on it.
                          Last edited by Kloccwork419; 03-19-2022, 07:19 PM.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by Kloccwork419 View Post
                            CONECA higher up are busy doing other things than being on a forum. Attributions arent even ready yet.

                            This isn't a listed "Variety". YET. So no, none will be graded as that. I have heard its going in the new CPG which I have no clue why. This will end up being some other made up CPG variety like the Re Engraved Lincolns or the No FG. Probably be huge when it's released and then end up being worth less than the plastic its in. You would be better off keeping it til the CPG is released for a #. Then youll have all them FS chasers on it.
                            They're busy doing other things and attributions aren't even ready yet.......... So what are they doing? What's the point of this forum?

                            You heard it's going to be in the new CPG and you have no clue why........ Maybe because the author and "real attributors" say it's a new variety.

                            You might be right, it could be another made up CPG variety......... or maybe another Cheerios dollar.

                            But you're right, it's not a listed "Variety" YET!

                            This is as HIGH as a "CONECA" variety has gotten. ICG!
                            Attached Files

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Wrong again. Not sure why you’re here. Because you have an elongated ray and think your special?
                              This forum was here before they took over attributions. Can tell with the couple comments already you have no idea what you’re talking about and came here just to run your mouth.
                              So keep doing it, I wont see your next comment because the ignore option works great here. So keep crying to whoever will listen. I wont see it

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X